There is no difference between these two. Because socialism is the buzzword being used, I’ll use it most often but these ideas result in the same condition — a military dictatorship and authoritarian regime of the ugliest kind. Anyone who argues with that needs, to hear the words of Lenin:
“The goal of socialism is communism”
Vladimir Lenin
There’s a lot of talk about the various types of economic models, particularly capitalism, communism, and socialism. Among the hippies and ‘progressives’, socialism/communism is the best model. It’s all very Utopian and has beautiful promises with a horrific underbelly. Of course, it’s the beautiful promises that are talked about and glorified, and completely ignored is the the extremely high body count needed to implement and maintain communism as a form of government and economic model. At our current level of consciousness, I find it a very promising sign that so many people are aiming at a better world for all (means we have collectively chosen to serve the light!) but we do not yet have the awareness of our spiritual truth to really hold the promise into fruition. Instead, the good intentions of millions are being used the bad among us to pave a path to hell using bones and blood and broken dreams. Let me go into detail here.
Requires Disempowerment
Communism is a form of government which demands that every individual under their control abdicate (give up) all personal power. In fact, personal sovereignty is thrown into the trash can. Another way to say this is that the governing body requires that everyone be in their disempowered state – accepting of whatever the governing body decides is ‘best for them’. This right here is the biggest reason why it will never work – especially for a species which is trying find our way to owning our light – and why it is completely unenlightened. When personal responsibility is handed over to another body, we are giving away our power to do anything, literally. We are giving away our responsibility not only to and for ourselves but also everyone around us. The moment we do that is the moment we can wash our hands of the result. We would also live completely in Separation Consciousness – after all I am no longer responsible for your outcome. I outsourced that personal responsibility to someone else. I can shake my head, but I don’t have to actually do anything.
Enlightened individuals would never do that. Why? Primarily, the truly Enlightened know to the core of their Being the truth that we are all One. Knowing this in truth means I can never abdicate my responsibility. Never give away my power to do all I can to help Us.
“You must look to yourselves instead of looking to others, and become One.”
Metatron: This is the Clarion Call by R. Mackenzie.
Disempowered means Victim
When an entire culture has given away their power, they fall into being the victim. A victim is first off completely without responsibility for their situation They are the VICTIM, after all. And how dare anyone blame the victim! The victim blames others, demands others take responsibility. How easy is it to say “the government needs to solve all these problems!” Either because I refuse to acknowledge that I have any power or responsibility to work on some of these, or because it’s not seen as ‘my problem’ and therefore someone else needs to own it. As we all know, power given away is very hard to take back. Giving power to somebody outside of the self is pretty much the definition of disempowerment, and refusal to accept responsibility for the situation while demanding someone else take the blame is the definition of victim.
“Blame is the creed of the disempowered.”
Steve Mirabolic
No Control means Slavery
Oooh. I went there. That’s a deeply charged word right now, but slavery was a very human thing that has been with us since pretty much the instant that one human realized they could take all power away from another and make them do things. What does it mean to be a slave? It means that we are not free to choose for ourselves. We are not able to take responsibility for our life, because someone else is making those choices. What we are is utterly disempowered so that we have been convinced we are weak and either unworthy of having our sovereignty honored or we are too weak to enforce our sovereignty. We allow it to happen if we believe we deserve it.
Unworthy comes in many forms, but the modern manifestation is twofold. Demanding someone else accept responsibility, and demanding that someone else believe that they are horrible people just by being. The second one especially is ugly and definitely doesn’t even look in the direction of Enlightened.
“I didn’t know I was a slave until I found out I couldn’t do the things I wanted.”
Frederick Douglass (if you don’t know who this is, learn!! He’s impressive!!!)
Equality in Slavery
Yeonmi Park is an amazing and courageous young woman – an escapee from South Korea. She has faced the depths of human depravity, and also seen the potential we have for greatness. She tells the story of how North Korea became one giant slave state where 26 million people live in constant terror and deprivation to serve the pleasure of one man. It’s hair raising because the exact same language used then is being used again – right now. The promise of equality had pictures of the lowest peoples being raised to be equals with the highest. Lies. The people gave up their land and their personal responsibility and in return, they were stripped of everything and turned into a giant slave state that calls itself a Socialist Democracy. “Whaaaat?! They are lying??” Instead of being raised up, everyone was shoved into the dirt.
The people of Venezuela tell an eerily similar story – at least those refugees who are flooding into the US. They were lied to, tricked, and enslaved so that the insatiable greed of elitists could be satisfied. But greed is never satisfied. It’s a black hole of the ego. And those who are pushing the call of “equality” through communism / socialism are those same elitists – though the average person is largely ignorant of this. Hey it’s worked before. It’s the formula!
“There is in fact a manly and legitimate passion for equality that spurs all men to wish to be strong and esteemed. This passion tends to elevate the lesser to the rank of the greater. But one also finds in the human heart a depraved taste for equality, which impels the weak to want to bring the strong down to their level, and which reduces men to preferring equality in servitude to inequality in freedom.”
Alexis de Tocqueville
“You will own nothing” – not “WE will own nothing…”
They are telling us to our faces exactly what our fates will be if we agree to this.
“But universal wage!” In Venezuela, I’ve been told that is $6 a day. Wow. People are roaming the streets looking to kill rats and cats to have something to eat. Sound wonderful to you? I hope not. This also means that I would be an economic slave, unable to break out even if I wanted to. Take a look at the cycle of poverty and how hard that is to escape – and that’s not being enforced by people we abdicated our power to.
“But guaranteed housing!” Do you imagine a McMansion or a luxury condo? That’s for the corrupt elites who help support the regime. The regular people like you and me will be in hovels, serving our master’s pleasure – if we’re lucky. Complain too loudly? You disappear.
“But equality!” Everybody being a slave sounds like equality? Everybody equally impoverished, abused, and treated like trash sounds like an improvement?? Is that REALLY what is imagined when that mantra is used?
Equality of outcomes means you have no choice, no power, no ability to affect your situation. It’s the most nightmare statement I can think of. Equality of outcomes can be rephrased to “you’ll take what we decide to give you, and be happy … or else”. Does that sound enlightened?
Always remember – no government can give us something they didn’t take from someone else first.
“The theory of Communism can be summed up on one sentence: Abolish all private property”
Karl Marx
Government is your God – there can be no other God before that
Faith is the enemy of communism / socialism. Why? Because it gives hope, but more threatening is that it provides the possibility that there is a greater power out there than the ruling body. Well, that can’t be allowed! There can be NO authority higher than the ruling body, the masters.
Now I’m no fan of organized religion, but I recognize it has the potential to do good and it does. It also has the potential to be abused – and it is. If you so hate religion that you’d rather see all forms of it destroyed, what is it being replaced with? Has the name of the religion merely changed? After all, there is no more aggressive form of organized religion that communism. It holds all the authority, and is too greedy to consider sharing.
I’m much more about a personal relationship with whatever idea of divinity there is, and that divinity is not any form of human controlled government. And that’s what authoritarian dictatorships are the most terrified of – take a look at the extreme reaction that the CCP had the very spiritual practice of Falun Gong! Can you imagine the authoritarian reaction to “we are One, what happens to one happens to all, and I am responsible for my actions and how they impact the One All”? I’d be disappeared so fast!! Especially since I’m working to hold the light so others can realize their own lights.
“The only interesting thing about religion is how many people it’s slaughtered. Communism and Nazism [aka socialism] are religions as well, make no mistake about it.”
Lemmy Kilmister
Socialism / Communism Pretends to be about Love and Human Betterment – Pretends to hold the Moral High Ground
It’s a failed experiment – it’s so last century. Just as capitalism is a failed experiment, so too is communism / socialism. Indeed, it seems that capitalism when followed to the extreme end becomes communism since this madness is being pushed by the handful of monetary elitists who want ever more. That means kill anyone who opposes it (over 100 MILLION people were straight up murdered in the 20th century because of this, Hitler having one of the smallest body counts) and it means stomping on everyone else to the point where we are broken and too tired to resist. If we resist, we are Bad People – insert terms like ‘racist’, ‘supremacist’, ‘x-phobe’, etc. Those are bully tactics aimed at controlling behavior. Thug life! Is that the energy of a truly enlightened perspective?
Ultimately, the proof is in the pudding. Look at the many socialist and communist governments and throughout the short history that these ideas were proposed and see what they are like for the average person. Most of us will be the average person. Is that the life we want to have? I say heck no. Saying that all other attempts to implement this approach was corrupted but that won’t happen with us, well, that’s dangerously naive.
“Communism is not love. Communism is a hammer which we use to crush the enemy.”
Mao Zedong
That could never happen HERE… I’m too clever to fall for anything like that…
“Knowledge can never imprison you, but you can be captive to your ignorance.”
A.E. Samaan
Of course those believers in the US and Europe and Canada now have not been fooled. Not been lied to, misled. Programmed. That could never be! They are far too clever to fall for pretty lies and false dreams. They know for a fact that as soon as those pesky right-wingers are defeated, they will rise to glorious power and all of their visions of a Better World will come to fruition and they will be in charge of it.
But history says otherwise. The idealists who fought with Lenin? Executed. Those idealists who fought with Mao? Executed. Those idealists who fought with Kim Il-Sung? Executed. Pretty sure that was the fate of the idealists in Venezuela as well.
Does that sound like an enlightened movement? I hope not.
“[T]he useful idiots, the leftists who are idealistically believing in the beauty of the Soviet socialist or Communist or whatever system, when they get disillusioned, they become the worst enemies. That’s why my KGB instructors specifically made the point: never bother with leftists. Forget about these political prostitutes. Aim higher. […] They serve a purpose only at the stage of destabilization of a nation. For example, your leftists in the United States: all these professors and all these beautiful civil rights defenders. They are instrumental in the process of the subversion only to destabilize a nation. When their job is completed, they are not needed any more. They know too much. Some of them, when they get disillusioned, when they see that Marxist-Leninists come to power—obviously they get offended—they think that they will come to power. That will never happen, of course. They will be lined up against the wall and shot.”
Yuri Bezmenov (Soviet journalist and KGB informant prior to defecting)
In Conclusion, We do not yet have the consciousness to hold a true non-centralized collective cooperative
The Consciousness of humanity is rising. As a history buff, I can point to the growth of it over the last 4 centuries – but it has been a long, slow process. We are not yet expanded enough to hold a collective cooperative type of organization, especially at a large scale, which does not follow a centrist model. We just don’t have the framework yet. That said, in 2012 the expansion process got one heck of a boost! And the world is unraveling. All of the old systems are falling apart, and one of those is communism / socialism right along with capitalism. They are all systems which emphasize the wrong things. Right now, there is no new language to describe the ideal state that we’d like to strive for. Utopia doesn’t touch it because … ew. Where life is perfect and we never have to worry or strive for something? Have you not noticed that when humans do NOT have some form of struggle that we make shit up? As I’ve heard it said, “we eat our own heads”. A world like that would be miserable and everyone would be so depressed, just making the motions of going through life. Equilibrium is a perfect movie showing this potential.
“No one should suffer from the great delusion that any form of communism or socialism which promotes the dictatorship of the few instead of the initiative of the millions can produce a happier or more prosperous society.”
Charles E. Wilson
I heard one fellow describing his Degrowth model, and I gotta say, I really liked it – took me a while to hear that it was something other than communism repackaged though. The foundational premise? Leverage the millions (billions) to shift the value system which gives energy to the growth-at-all-costs mindset and has gotten us into this mess into something else – something in which we have enough, voluntarily. Rather than abdicating our personal power and responsibility to ourselves and our communities to some remote group of Elites who are ego black holes of greed, instead take the spiritually evolved path and own both our power and our responsibility so that we can each make this world into the beautiful and thriving place it was always meant to be.
A centralized government which holds the power while the individuals under their boots are weak and passive will never work. It will never deliver on the beautiful promises and seductive lies. It is morally bankrupt, feeds all the darkest elements of humanity such as separation consciousness, violence, greed, corruption, and selfishness. It relies on average people believing they are less than. How is that enlightened? It is not.
“No centralized government, no matter how big, how smart or how powerful, can effectively and efficiently control much of society in a beneficial way. On the contrary, big governments are inherently inefficient and harmful.”
Charles Koch
We are One and the Rising Consciousness
We are One. This is a spiritual Truth that is gaining traction – though I really hope it doesn’t take a century or two to really proliferate! I do not hate those who are other manifestations of me. The most devout Progressive, is me – and you. The most devout Conservative, is me – and you. The centrist shaking their head at them both is also me – and you. I cannot shake someone out of a position of hate or greed or separation consciousness by using their tools of hate, anger, violence, and separation. I only do it by using love, sincerity, curiosity, and hopefully leading them into their own illogic via questions and active engagement.
I recognize that a centralized power leveraging a beautiful dream for dark ends can only do so because that dream is there in the first place. As I’ve said above, I find this extremely inspiring. It tells me that we have chosen, though we are still operating under the illusion of separation. We have chosen to embrace the path of service to others, the path of light, but we have the remnants of thousands of years of inertia and cultural programing to slough off first. That’s not an easy process!! It will take us a few generations, at a minimum, but it’s underway. And while those who serve the path of darkness (how dramatic sounding!) are trying to circumvent things, I do not believe they can. They can delay it, but not stop it. The choice has been made.
“The twentieth century will have taught us that no doctrine in itself is necessarily a liberating force: all of them may be perverted or take a wrong turning; all have blood on their hands – communism, liberalism, nationalism, each of the great religions, and even secularism. Nobody has a monopoly on humane values.”
Amin Maalouf